There was no January 1920 issue due to a printer’s strike.  | 
   | 
  
  | 
   | 
  
  | 
   | 
  
  | 
   | 
  
  | 
   | 
  
  | 
   | 
  
  | 
  
 25th Anniversary Issue.  | 
   | 
  
 Issue not indexed.  | 
  
  | 
  
 Issue not indexed.  | 
  
  | 
   | 
  
 Details supplied by Mike Ashley.  | 
  
  | 
   | 
  
 Issue not indexed.  | 
  
 Issue not indexed.  | 
  
 Issue not indexed.  | 
  
 Issue not indexed.  | 
  
 Issue not indexed.  | 
  
 Issue not indexed.  | 
   | 
  
 Issue not indexed.  | 
  
 Details taken from eBay listing.  | 
   | 
  
 Issue not indexed.  | 
  
 Associated editors R. C. Smith, Magda Leigh, A. N. Kane. Details supplied by Alistair Durie.  | 
   | 
  
 Issue not indexed.  | 
  
 Details taken from Table of Contents.  | 
   | 
  
 “Original Stories by the Best Authors” on cover. “A Monthly Magazine of Short Stories and Bright Literature by the Best Writers” subtitle on colophon.  | 
  
  | 
  
  | 
  
  | 
  
  | 
  
  | 
  
  | 
  
  | 
  
  | 
  
  | 
  
  | 
  
  | 
  
  | 
  
  | 
  
  | 
  
  | 
  
  | 
  
  | 
  
  | 
  
  | 
  
  | 
  
  | 
  
  | 
  
 Top of cover reads “The Black Cat Penny Stories No. 24” Middle of cover as before Middle right reads “Penny Stories. A Monthly Illustrated Journal for the Home”  | 
  
 Top of cover reads “The Black Cat Penny Stories No. 25” Middle of cover as before Middle right reads “Penny Stories. A Monthly Illustrated Journal for the Home”  | 
  
 Semi-professional magazine. One of many publications issued by George Henderson, a prominent Toronto dealer in “nostalgia” merchandise. This collection of public domain reprints was his only all-fiction title.  | 
  
  | 
   | 
  
 Mixture of reprint and new stories, both mystery and supernatural. All issues of this magazine have the same cover illustration—the head of a black cat in a circle.  | 
  
  | 
  
  | 
   | 
  
  | 
   | 
  
  | 
   | 
  
 Title changed from Black Cat Mystery Magazine.  | 
  
  | 
   | 
  
  | 
   | 
  
  | 
   | 
  
 Details taken from magazine website.  | 
   | 
  
 Details supplied by Darrell Schweitzer.  | 
   | 
  
 Details taken from Table of Contents.  | 
   | 
  
 Details taken from online listing.  | 
   | 
  
 Details taken from Table of Contents.  | 
   | 
  
 Details taken from Table of Contents.  | 
   | 
  
 Special Private Eye Issue. Details taken from Table of Contents.  | 
   | 
  
 Executive editor John Gregory Betancourt. Detail supplied by Richard Krauss.  | 
   | 
  
 Detail supplied by Richard Krauss.  | 
   | 
  
 Details supplied by Richard Krauss.  | 
   | 
  
 Details taken from Table of Contents.  | 
   | 
  
 Details taken from Table of Contents.  | 
   |