- October 1, 2018:
- · Fall Arrives · The Editors · ed
- October 15, 2018:
- · Interview with Travis Perry · [uncredited] · iv [Ref. Travis Perry]
- October 22, 2018:
- · A Halloween Hymn · Eric James Stone · ss
- November 5, 2018:
- · The Queue and You · The Editors · ed
- November 19, 2018:
- · Interview with Catherine Jones Payne · [uncredited] · iv [Ref. Catherine Jones Payne]
- November 26, 2018:
- · A Relic Most Rare · Rebecca Birch · ss
- December 3, 2018:
- · Advent Greetings · The Editors · ed
- December 16, 2018:
- · Interview with Kirk DouPonce · [uncredited] · iv [Ref. Kirk DouPonce]
- December 24, 2018:
- · The Chora Gate · Stephen Case · ss
- January 7, 2019:
- · Another Year, Another Submission Window · The Editors · ed
- January 14, 2019:
- · Lepers · Keyan Bowes · ss M June 2016
- January 28, 2019:
- · The City Above the Shelf · Frederick Gero Heimbach · ss
- February 4, 2019:
- · Submissions End, The Work Begins · The Editors · ed
- February 25, 2019:
- · Absence · Joanne Rixon · ss
- March 4, 2019:
- · March-April Fiction Lineup · The Editors · ed
- March 25, 2019:
- · The Sojourn of Pope Packard the Third · Jared Oliver Adams · nv
- April 1, 2019:
- · Patreon Update and More · The Editors · ed
- April 8, 2019:
- · Plain Jane Learns to Knit Wormholes · Wendy Nikel · vi Flash Fiction Online #47, August 2017
- April 22, 2019:
- · The Book · S. E. Reid · ss
- May 6, 2019:
- · May Updates · The Editors · ed
- May 27, 2019:
- · Meeting at the Crossroads · Joel Limmer · ss
- June 3, 2019:
- · New Submission Period Approaching · The Editors · ed
- June 24, 2019:
- · The Mark · Forrest Brazeal · ss
- July 1, 2019:
- · New Submission Window, New Pay Rate, New Stories · The Editors · ed
- July 8, 2019:
- · Whoever Is Not for Us · G. Scott Huggins · ss
- July 22, 2019:
- · Saint Denis and the Pot of Basil · Catherine Heloise · ss
- August 5, 2019:
- · End of the Submission Period · The Editors · ed
- August 26, 2019:
- · The Orderly · Elise Forier Edie · ss
- September 2, 2019:
- · 2019 Publishing Schedule, Monthly Chats, and More! · The Editors · ed
- September 23, 2019:
- · Whatsoever Ye Shall Ask · Joanna Michal Hoyt · ss
- October 7, 2019:
- · Submissions Progress · The Editors · ed
- October 28, 2019:
- · Smokeless · Laura VanArendonk Baugh · nv
- November 4, 2019:
- · Fall Attractions · The Editors · ed
- November 25, 2019:
- · Fools Pass Under · Kat Otis · ss
- December 2, 2019:
- · Beginning of Advent · The Editors · ed
- December 9, 2019:
- · The Stranger in the Manger · Wendy Nikel · ss
- December 23, 2019:
- · A Very Spaced-Out Christmas · Madison McSweeney · ss
- January 6, 2020:
- · Arisia 2020 Schedules (And More!) · The Editors · ed
- January 13, 2020:
- · A Moose for Jesus · Patricia S. Bowne · ss
- January 27, 2020:
- · In the Fields of Sin, Down Among the Dead · Brian Winfrey · ss
- February 3, 2020:
- · Award-Eligible 2019 Stories from Mysterion · The Editors · ed
- February 24, 2020:
- · His Ministers a Flame of Fire · T. B. Jeremiah · ss
- March 2, 2020:
- · Lent, Submissions Progress, and Patreon · The Editors · ed
- March 16, 2020:
- · The Expanse, Season 4 · Stephen Case · mr
- March 23, 2020:
- · Reformed · Caias Ward · ss
- April 6, 2020:
- · Mysterion in the Time of Coronavirus · The Editors · ed
- April 27, 2020:
- · God-Eaters · Joshua M. Young · ss
- May 4, 2020:
- · Boston in the Spring · The Editors · ed
- May 25, 2020:
- · Gordon’s Knot · Jennifer Milne · ss
- June 22, 2020:
- · Work in Progress · Mike Ekunno · ss
- July 13, 2020:
- · You Shall See Him in the East · Frederick Gero Heimbach · ss
- July 27, 2020:
- · The Woeful Tale of Sir Banana · Rachael K. Jones · ss
- August 24, 2020:
- · What Comes Before · John Nadas · ss
- September 28, 2020:
- · Michael · Em Liu · ss
- October 26, 2020:
- · The Original Sin of William Blackhand · R. Keelan · ss
- November 23, 2020:
- · Omnipotent Marble · Patrick Doerksen · ss
- December 28, 2020:
- · This Is the Way the Prayer Ends · Barbara A. Barnett · ss
- January 11, 2021:
- · Did You Hear the Angels Sing? · H. L. Fullerton · ss
- January 25, 2021:
- · Devil Dog · Len Bailey · ss
- February 22, 2021:
- · Salvation · John Nadas · ss
- March 22, 2021:
- · Milestone and the Fifth World · Marissa James · ss
- April 26, 2021:
- · The Secret Place of the Lord · J. L. Royce · ss
- May 24, 2021:
- · Breaching the Distance · Hannah Onoguwe · nv
- June 28, 2021:
- · The Cure · A. J. Cunder · ss
- July 12, 2021:
- · Bearing the Flame · C. A. Barrett · ss
- July 26, 2021:
- · Ceiling Snakes and Slithering Saints · Barbara A. Barnett · ss
- August 23, 2021:
- · Vocation · Jessica Snell · ss
- September 27, 2021:
- · Kirishitan · Marshall J. Moore · ss
- October 25, 2021:
- · An Exchange of Values, Conducted in Good Faith · David Tallerman · nv
- November 22, 2021:
- · The Inksmith · Katherine Briggs · ss
- December 27, 2021:
- · Soul’s Wager · K. J. Khan · ss
- January 10, 2022:
- · The Gift of Tongues · Annaliese Lemmon · ss Mormon Lit Blitz June 4 2016
- January 24, 2022:
- · The Remnant · Cathy Smith · ss
- February 28, 2022:
- · Moral Panic 1986 · Marshall J. Moore · ss
- March 28, 2022:
- · Help · O. Z. A. Lee · ss
- April 25, 2022:
- · On Charis Station · D. G. P. Rector · nv
- May 23, 2022:
- · The Trial of Corin of Westfyr · K. J. Khan · ss
- June 27, 2022:
- · Grandad and the Lockbox · Andrew Hansen · ss
- July 11, 2022:
- · Mark the Days · Kat Heckenbach · nv Mythic Orbits Vol. 2 ed. Travis Perry, Bear Publications, July 2018
- July 25, 2022:
- · The Gift to Be Healed · Annaliese Lemmon · ss Drops of Pain and Promise by Annaliese Lemmon, self-published, May 2021
- August 22, 2022:
- · The Tithe · Frederick Gero Heimbach · ss
- September 26, 2022:
- · The Practical Ending · Alex Sobel · ss
- October 24, 2022:
- · Heretic · E. Rathke · ss
- November 28, 2022:
- · My Soul, and with the Sun · Duke Kimball · ss
- December 26, 2022:
- · Christmas in Apocalypse · Karl El-Koura · ss
- January 9, 2023:
- · The Baptismal Status of Persons Wetted by the Sprinkler Deluge · Andy Dibble · vi Sci Phi Journal Winter 2021
- January 23, 2023:
- · Daughter of Omega · Matthew P. Schmidt · ss
- February 27, 2023:
- · The Binding and the Ram · D. G. P. Rector · nv
- March 27, 2023:
- · MARY and Martha · T. R. Frazier · ss
- April 24, 2023:
- · Wicket 2.0 · Jamie M. Boyd · ss
- May 22, 2023:
- · No Stranger to Desert Places · Karen Eisenbrey · ss
- June 25, 2023:
- · Stained Glass · Mob · ss
- July 10, 2023:
- · The Cockatrice Den · Joanna Michal Hoyt · ss
- July 24, 2023:
- · The Church of the UPC · Jeff Hewitt · ss
- August 28, 2023:
- · The Carelessness of Endless Summers · Ann McCurdy · ss
- September 25, 2023:
- · The Virgin · Jaye Nasir · ss
- October 23, 2023:
- · Among the Birds · Will Greatwich · ss
- November 27, 2023:
- · Devil in the Rain · D. G. P. Rector · nv
- December 25, 2023:
- · Twelfth Night · Jonathan Edward McDonald · ss
- January 8, 2024:
- · Thomas the Doubter · Patrick Hurley · ss
- January 22, 2024:
(continued)
- · Soulman · Ralph Mack · ss