Review by Sally Startup
This novella, set in Paris, 1866, has the same narrator as The Legacy of
Erich Zann. Yet again, Mr Poe's American correspondent and Auguste
Dupin are called upon to solve a puzzling murder.
Dupin is interested in the developing science of animal magnetism,
and has been observing how some charlatans have used the theory and
practice of mesmerism to mislead the gullible. One person willing to pay
for dubious spiritual cures is the famous writer Honoré de Balzac.
Dupin understands the dangers of belief in this kind of magic, although
still wishing to preserve the writers' health.
The arrival in Paris of the unusual remains of Mr Valdemar, who is
finally, completely dead, is of potential interest to many. Since Mr Poe
published a sensationalist account of the events preceding Valdemar's
death, efforts have been made to pass it off as fiction, so further
developments have been kept secret. It is left to Dupin and his
rationally-minded friend to uncover the secrets and ambitions of
Valdemar's daughter. In the process, they are led to consider what they
know about mesmerism, and what that might imply, thus providing a
fascinating study for interested readers.