Welcome to www.EllisParkerButler.Info SIGN-IN
Welcome to www.EllisParkerButler.Info, the best place on the Internet to find information about the life and work of Ellis Parker Butler, American humorist and author.

Reading Room

"Ten Humor Rules Given by Author of 'Pigs is Pigs'" from Los Angeles Evening Herald

text only format text only  printer friendly format printer friendly

  • Los Angeles Evening Herald (March 9, 1920)   "Ten Humor Rules Given by Author of 'Pigs is Pigs'"   Written by Adela Rogers St. John (b. 1894, d. 1988). Includes a photo of the author (the same photo as printed in July 1925 issue of Sunset Magazine) and a photo of the elder Butler with his son Ellis Olmsted (called "Ellis, Jr." in the caption). The similarly named article in Photoplay Magazine reprints major portions of this article. Ms. St. John was acting as publicist for King Vidor's film company (First National Pictures), which made the motion picture version of "Jack-Knife Man" this same year. Page 1 of Section 2.  [EPBLIB, HARPER]

from Los Angeles Evening Herald
Ten Humor Rules Given by Author of 'Pigs is Pigs'

Laugh and the world laughs with you,
Weep, and you weep alone.
For the sad old earth must borrow its mirth,
But has trouble enough of its own.

The average man cherishes a sneaking wish that Providence had seen fit to allow him to say a few words on his own behalf upon certain occasions. One of these is when the minister rises to remark, "Friends, the character of the deceased, as known to us --"

Another is during the distribution of gifts by a fairy godmother, alleged to take place immediately after his first entrance.

If he could speak instead of squawl at the time, about nine out of ten probably would demand the gift of laughter, laughing, making others laugh, being, in other words, one of the little old bankers from whom the world borrows its mirth.

Being unable to put this over at that time, he tries in after years to acquire this gift.


And now comes one Ellis Parker Butler, who deposes and says that there are rules for making laughs, just like there are rules for making pies, and gives the poor layman ten commandments for making merriment.

"There is no situation," says Mr. Butler, "which will not produce laughter if it is put through a given process subjected to given rules."

Ellis Parker Butler's chief claim to fame will probably always remain the fact that he wrote "Pigs is Pigs." He may write -- has written -- other books which rank higher in literary merit, in actual comedy, such as "The Jack Knife Man," but "Pigs IS Pigs."

I discovered the humorist in a Covina bungalow, positively hiding, incognito, as it were, among the orange trees and mountains, his presence unknown to his closest friends. With Mrs. Butler and all the little Butlers, four in number, he is enjoying California winter weather, writing a new novel, and overseeing preparation for the screening of his novel, "The Jack Knife Man," for the motion picture rights of which King W. Vidor recently paid $13,000.

"How do you make people laugh?" quoth I.

"Well," said he, "y'know you can get just as big a laugh by poking a baby in the ribs as you can by composing the finest line in the world. There isn't much degree in laughter. Humor is largely mechanical. It has certain paces, rules, systems. I may almost say there are Ten Rules of Humor, as clearly defined as the Ten Commandments. All humor is merely a variation of these methods.


"Wit, however, is different and originates in the mind. Goethe once said that every bonmot he coined had at least $25 worth of education, reading and knowledge back of it."

"The First Method of Humor is what I might call a breezy exaggeration. It predominates in American humor. It is an inflated chest exaggeration. It predominates in American humor. It is an inflated chest exaggeration. You take something only slightly important and permit it to grow, to wax large, until it is extremely important. A slight variation from the normal, aggrandized, enlarged tremendously. is a cure-fire success. Mark Twain was fond of this style.

"Second, we have the use of the other person's real or pretended ignorance. Almost all child humor is founded upon the child's ignorance of something we fully understand. International and rural humor of various kinds emanate from this. Wrong use of words, or, even to go further, another person's faults or peculiarities, may be classed here.


"Third is what I call the naive mode, which Barrie so often employed in his early Scotch stories. By that I mean a seriousness, an alertness, about something that is really impossible, absurd or ridiculous. For example, I read a story just the other day about a postage stamp society which, at a meeting called to deplore the unornamental designs of postage stamps, appointed a committee to do away with the plain stamp now used in the United States and persuade the government to issue a series of stamps displaying the scenery of California.

That is the height of naive humor.

"Fourth is the ridiculous, the calling direct attention to something we consider impossible in connection with ourselves -- the fat man, in the silk hat, on a slippery pavement for instance. This probably is not funny to fat men in silk hats on slippery pavements.


"Fifth, the repetition of something more or less unexpected. 'Pigs is Pigs' is an excellent illustration of this. It starts as a sane story about an express company, an express man and a pair of expressed guinea pigs.

"Due to the well known rapidity of guinea pigs in multiplying, every time the express man comes 'round there are a few more pigs. Then there are a lot more. Each time, it's funnier. The laugh grows heavier. This is what I call beating upon the drum of humor.

"Sixth is the sudden let down from the extremely serious to the extremely frivolous. Mark Twain uses this where he is describing a young man who receives a severe calling down. The arraignment is noble and serious, solemn. But when he described the young man, he says he reminded him of a spider dropped on a hot skillet. First, a look of wild surprise, then he shrivelled.


"The sixth example likewise explains the seventh method, the use of extreme analogy, calling attention to an agreement or likeness between things in some circumstances or effects when the things are otherwise entirely different. This is the basis of many cartoons.

"The eighth is the more or less disguised practical joke, horse play, physical humor -- the custard pie in the face. Strangely enough, if this is led up to in the right way, it is not raw or coarse, but is apt to be more effective than any other form of humor.

"Ninth is the gradual expansion of an idea that has ridiculous possibilities, on the theory that if a little of a good thing is good, more is better.

"The tenth is intempestivity, untimeliness, something that has no particular humor in itself happening at an opportune time -- mal a propos humor. For example, things happening at a funeral, a wedding, a christening, or a gathering of a serious nature.


"Of course, it is understood that the author and the reader set themselves up as a superior set of persons. Humor is always laughing at something and the author must convey the impression that he and the reader are laughing together at something.

"Characterization is not humor. Characterization is the setting for humor. The better the setting, the more effective the humor. The contrast of action is more sharply defined. Things are often funny because of the character of the person who does them.

"The after dinner speaker who starts out by saying 'Mike and Pat were walking down the street one day' is the bunk. Everybody at the table knows instantly that he has taken a stock setting -- or no setting -- for some words. That is not humor.

"The great American novel? A myth -- a symbol -- an impossibility. None can write THE great American novel any more than he can describe the spectrum in one word."



Saturday, October 07 at 1:17:35am USA Central
This web site is Copyright © 2006 by the ANDMORE Companies. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
Images for viewing only. All copyrights remain with the holder. No covers or publications for sale.
www.EllisParkerButler.Info is a research project of the ANDMORE Companies, Houston TX USA.