| Originally named  Bestseller Mystery | 
| 1937 
 
 | 1937, ? date No. 1 Adventures of Ellery Queen | 1937, ? year No. 2 One More Spring by Robert Nathan | 1937, ? year No. 3 More Adventures of Ellery Queen | 1937, ? year No. 4 Life Begins at Forty by Walter B. Pitkin, Abridged | 1937, ? year No. 5 Tobacco Road by Jack Kirkland (Erskine Caldwell) | 1937, ? year No. 6 24 Hours by Louis Bromfield | 1937, ? year No. 7 The Bellamy Trail (abridged) by Frances Noyes Hart | 
| 1938 
 
 | 1938,  No. 8 The Devil to Pay by Ellery Queen | 1938, ? year No. 9 
  The Mysterious Mr. Quin (Abridged) by Agatha Christie
 | 1938, ? date No. 10 The Case of the Curious Bride (abridged) by Erfe Stanley Gardner | 1938, ? date No. 11 The Spanish Cape Mystery (abridged) by Ellery Queen | 1938, ? date No. 12 Thank You, Mr. Moto by John P. Marquand | 1938, ? date No. 13 Lord Peter Views the Body by Dorothy L. Sayers | 1938, ? date No. 14 The Greek Coffin Mystery by Ellery Queen | 1938, ? date No. 15 Inquest by Percival Wilde | 
| 1939 
 
 | 1939, ? date No. 16 
  Murder in Stained Glass (abridged) by Margaret Armstrong
 | 1939, ? date No. 17 The Egyptian Cross Mystery (abridged) by Ellery Queen | 1939, ? date No. 18 
  Dead Man's Mirror by Agatha Christie
 | 1939, ? year No. 19 The Case of the Sleepwalker's Niece (abridged) by Erle Stanley Gardner | 1939, ? year No. 20 
  In the Teeth of the Evidence by Dorothy L. Sayers
 | 1939, ? year No. 21 
  Murder in 3 Acts by Agatha Christie
 | 1939,  No. 22 The D.A. Holds the Candle by Erle Stanley Gardner | 1939,  No. 23 
  Death in Ecstasy by Ngaio March
 | 
| 1940 
 
 | 
| 1941 
 
 | 1941,  No. 24 
  A Face for a Clue by Georges Simenon
 | 1941, ? year No. 25 Partners in Crime (abridged) by Agatha Christie | 1941, ? year No. 26 | 1941,  No. 27 
  The Cairo Garter Murders (abridged) by Van Wyck Mason
 | 1941, ? year No. 28 The Tragedy Of Y by Ellery Queen | 1941, ? year No. 29 Murder Up My Sleeve by Erle Stanley Gardner | 1941, ? year No. 30 The Man With No Face (abridged) by Margaret Armstrong | 
| 1942 
 
 | 
| 1943 
 
 | 1943,  No. 31 
  Some Buried Caesar by Rex Stout
 | 1943, ? year No. 32 
  The Seven Dials Mystery by Agatha Christie
 | 1943, ? year No. 33 
  Black Plumes by Margery Allingham
 | 1943,  No. 34 
  Department of Queer Complaints by Carter Diskson
 | 1943, ? year No. 35 This is Murder by Erle Stanley Gardner | 1943, ? year No. 36 
  The Regatta Mystery and Other Stories by Agatha Christie
 | 1943,  No. 37 
  The Whispering Cup by Mabel Seeley
 | 1943, ? year No. 38 
  Hangman's Holiday by Dorothy L. Sayers
 | 1943, ? year No. 39 
  The Boomerang Clue by Agatha Christie
 | 1943,  No. 40 
  $106,000 Blood Money - Dashiell Hammett
 | 1943, ? year No. 41 
  The Flemish Shop by Georges Simenon
 | 1943,  No. 42 
  The G-String Murders by Gypsy Rose Lee
 | 1943, ? year No. 43 Poirot Investigates by Agatha Christie | 
| 1943 
 
 | 1943,  No. 44 Where There Is a Will by Rex Stout | 
| 1944 
 
 | 1944,  No. 45 
  Death In Five Boxes by Carter Dickson
 | 1944, ? year No. 46 Death In The Doll's House by Hannah & Lawrence Bachmann Lees | 1944,  No. 47 The Three Coffins by John Dickson Carr | 1944, ? date No. 48 
  The Secret Adversary by Agatha Christie
 | 1944, ? year No. 49 The Dark Garden by Mignon G. Eberhart | 1944,  No. 50 
  The Adventures of Sam Spade and other stories by Dashiell Hammett
 | 1944, ? year No. 51 
  Police At The Funeral by Margery Allingham
 | 1944,  No. 52 
  The Man in the Brown Suit, by Agatha Christie
 | 1944, ? year No. 53 
  Thirty days Hath September by Dorthy Cameron Disney & George Sessions Perry
 | 1944, ? year No. 54 
  Sad Cypress by Agatha Christie
 | 1944, ? year No. 55 The Pattern by Mignon G. Eberhart | 1944, ? year No. 56 Kingdom of Death by Margery Allingham | 1944, ? year No. 57 Washington Legation Murders by Van Wyck Mason | 
| 1944 
 
 | 1944, ? year No. 58 
  APPOINTMENT WITH DEATH by Agatha Christie
 | 1944, ? year No. 59 The Case Book Of Ellery Queen by Ellery Queen | 1944, ? year No. 60 
  The Hangman's Whip by Mignon G. Eberhart
 | 1944, ? year No. 61 
  Murder at Hazelmoor by Agatha Christe
 | 
| 1945 
 
 | 1945,  No. 62 
  The Continental Op by Dashiell Hammett
 | 1945, ? year No. 63 The Budapest Parade Murders by F. Van Wyck Mason | 1945, ? year No. 64 
  Artists in Crime by Ngaio Marsh
 | 1945, ? year No. 65 A Compound For Death by Doris M. Disney | 1945, ? year No. 66 
  The Alarm of the Black Cat by D.B. Olson
 | 1945, ? year No. 67 
  Dagger Of The Mind by Kenneth Fearing
 | 1945, ? year No. 68 
  Vintage Murder by Ngaio Marsh
 | 1945, ? year No. 69 
  The Patience of Maigret by Georges Simenon
 | 1945, ? year No. 70 Deadly Nightshade by Elizabeth Daly | 1945, ? year No. 71 
  The Crimson Circle by Edgar Wallace
 | 1945, ? year No. 72 Parchment Key by Stanley Hopkins | 1945, ? year No. 73 
  The Affair of the Crimson Gull by Clifford Knight
 | 1945, ? year No. 74 | 
| 1945 
 
 | 1945, ? year No. 75 Miss Silver Deals With Death by Patricia Wentworth | 1945,  No. 76 
  The Pricking Thumb by H.C. Branson
 | 1945, ? year No. 77 
  While She Sleeps by Ethel Lina White
 | 1945,  No. 78 Death Watch by John Dickson Carr | 1945, ? year No. 79 
  Mr. Parker Pyne, Detective by Agatha Christie
 | 1945, ? year No. 80 The Chuckling Fingers by Mabel Seeley | 
| 1946 
 
 | 1946,  No. 81 
  Hammett Homicides by Dashiell Hammett
 | 1946,  No. 82 
  Quoth The Raven by Bruno Fischer
 | 1946,  No. 83 She Fell Among Actors by James Warren | 1946, ? year No. 84 Sinners Never Die by  A.E. Martin | 1946, ? year No. 85 The Black Honeymoon by Constance & Gwenyth Little (abridged) | 1946, ? year No. 86 Murder in the Calais Coach by Agatha Christie | 1946, ? year No. 87 The Corpse With The Purple Thighs by George Bagby | 1946,  No. 88 
  Whisper Murder by Vera Kelsey
 | 1946, ? year No. 89 The Blonde Died First by Dana Chambers | 1946, ? date No. 90 
  Deadline at Dawn by William Irish
 | 
| 1947 
 
 | 1947,  No. 91 
  The Department of Dead Ends by Roy Vickers
 | 1947, ? year No. 92 | 1947,  No. 93 The Book Of The Dead by Elizabeth Daly | 1947, ? year No. 94 Cops And Robbers by O. Henry | 1947, ? year No. 95 The Yellow Room by Mary Roberts Rinehart | 1947,  No. 96 
  Dead at the take-off by Lester Dent
 | 1947,  No. 97 The Man Who Slept All Day by Michael Yenning | 1947,  No. 98 Stranger At Home by George Sanders (Leigh Brackett) | 1947, ? date No. 99 Cats Don't Need Coffins by D.B.Olsen | 1947, ? year No. 100 
  The Hawk by Roy Vickers
 | 1947, ? year No. 101 
  Lady To Kill Cover by Lester Dent
 | 
| 1948 
 
 | 1948,  No. 102 Kiss The Blonde Goodbye by Finlay McDermid | 1948,  No. 103 Rope For An Ape by Dana Chambers | 1948,  No. 104 Fear No More by Leslie Edgley | 1948,  No. 105 So Deadly Fair by Gertrude Walker | 1948,  No. 106 The Bleeding Scissors by Bruno Fischer | 1948, ? year No. 107 Make My Bed Soon by John Stephen Strange | 1948, ? year No. 108 Murder Picks The Jury by Harrison Hunt | 1948, ? year No. 109 The Angry Heart by Leslie Edgley | 
| 1949 
 
 | 1949,  No. 110 
  Bullets for a Blonde by Will Oursler
 | 1949,  No. 111 Death For My Beloved by Doris Miles Disney | 1949,  No. 112 The Book of the Lion by Elizabeth Daly | 1949,  No. 113 In Cold Blood by George Bagby | 1949, ? year No. 114 The Blue Horse Of Taxco by Kathleen Moore Knight | 1949,  No. 115 Lady Afraid by Lester Dent | 1949, ? year No. 116 Fountain Of Death by Hugh Lawrence Nelson | 1949, ? year No. 117 Death Has Four Hands by Hilda Lawrence | 1949, ? year No. 118 Short Shrift by Manning Long | 1949, ? year No. 119 The Dark River by Philip Clark | 1949, ? year No. 120 Devious Design by D.B. Olsen | 1949, ? date No. 121 
  Nightfall by David Goodis
 | 1949, ? date No. 122 The Bleeding House by Hilda Lawrence | 
| 1949 
 
 | 1949, ? year No. 123 Bait For Murder by Kathleen Moore Knight | 1949, ? year No. 124 Think Fast Mr. Moto by John Marquand | 1949,  No. 126 
  For the Love of Murder by Maragret Scherf
 | 1949,  No. 127 The Dark Light by Bart Spicer | 
| 1950 
 
 | 1950,  No. 125 Shark River by Richard Powell | 1950,  No. 128 The Monkey Murder and other Hildegarde Withers stories by Stuart Palmer | 1950, ? year No. 129 
  Place for a Poisoner by E. C. R. Lorac
 | 1950, ? year No. 130 Kill to Fit by Bruno Fischer | 1950, ? year No. 131 Kill 'Em With Kindness by Fred Dickenson | 1950, ? year No. 132 Days of Misfortune by Aaron Marc Stein | 1950, ? year No. 133 Too Like The Dead by Dana Chambers | 1950, ? year No. 134 A Lonely Way To Die by Hal Debrett | 1950, ? year No. 135 
  Murder For Millions (Emily Will Know) by Nancy Rutledge
 | 1950, ? year No. 136 Blood On My Shoe by Jean Leslie | 1950, ? year No. 137 He Didn't Mind Danger by Michael Gilbert | 1950, ? year No. 138 The Whitebird Murders by Thomas B. Black | 1950, ? year No. 139 Death Of A Big Shot by Clifford Knight | 
| 1950 
 
 | 1950,  No. 140 
  Rather Cool For Mayhem by Lawrence G. Blochman
 | 1950, ? year No. 141 Sinister Shelter by Charles L. Leonard | 1950, ? year No. 142 | 1950, ? year No. 143 Murder Makes a Deadline by Samuel Michael Fuller | 
| 1951 
 
 | 1951,  No. 144 Mr. Blessington's Imperialist Plot by John Sherwood | 1951, ? date No. 145 
  Half Past Mortem by John A. Saxon
 | 1951, ? year No. 146 The Knife Behind You by James Benet | 1951,  No. 147 The Man in the Mist by Francis Bonnamy | 1951, ? year No. 148 
  "Smallbone Deceased" by Michael Gilbert
 | 1951,  No. 149 These Arrows Point To Death by William O'Farrell | 1951, ? year No. 150 The Kahuna Killer by Juanita Sheridan | 1951, ? year No. 151 The 3-13 Murders by Thomas Black | 1951,  No. 152 Alias Basil Willing by Helen McCloy | 1951, ? year No. 153 | 1951, ? date No. 154 "Fatal Lover (The Last Resort)" by Van Stiller | 
| 1952 
 
 | 1952,  No. 155 The Mamo Murders  by Juanita Sheridan | 1952, ? year No. 156 Don't Kill My Love by Rae Foley | 1952, ? year No. 157 "F" As in Flight by Lawrence Treat | 1952, ? year No. 158 Mask for Murder by Aaron Stein | 1952, ? year No. 159 Divine And Deadly by Margaret Scherf | 1952, ? year No. 160 Dead Ringer by Ferguson Findley | 1952, ? year No. 161 The Fair And The Dead by John Stephen Strange | 1952,  No. 162 Murder Is a Gamble by Glenn M. Barns | 1952, ? year No. 163 Lust For Vengeance by Robert Bloomfield | 1952, ? year No. 164 Death, My Darling Daughters by Jonathan Stagge | 1952, ? year No. 165 Vice Squad by Leslie T. White | 1952, ? year No. 166 Dance Of Death by Helen McCloy | 1952, ? year No. 167 The Virgin Huntress by Elisabeth Sanxay Holding | 
| 1952 
 
 | 1952, ? year No. 168 Dead Yesterday by Ruth Fenisong | 1952,  No. 169 
  One Murder Too Many by Edwin Lanham
 | 
| 1953 
 
 | 1953, ? year No. 170 
  Make Haste to Live by The Gordons
 | 1953, ? year No. 171 One Blonde Died by Leslie Edgley | 1953, ? year No. 172 Killer Loose! by Genevieve Holden | 1953,  No. 173 
  The Corpse Who Had Too Many Friends by Hampron Stone
 | 1953, ? year No. 174 
  This Year's Death by John Godey
 | 1953,  No. 175 
  Lawyers Don't Hang by Glenn M. Barns
 | 
| 1954 
 
 | 1954, ? year No. 176 The Passionate Victims by Lange Lewis | 1954, ? year No. 177 Terror Lurks In Darkness by Delores Hitchens | 1954, ? year No. 178 V as in Victim by Lawrence Treat | 1954, ? year No. 179 Lovely In Death by William O'Farrell | 
| 1955 
 
 | 1955, ? year No. 180 Killer at His Back (abridged) by John Godey | 1955, ? date No. 181 You'll Fry Tomorrow by M.v. Heberden | 1955, ? year No. 182 The Case of the Missing Corpse by Edwin Lanham | 1955, ? year No. 183 Embrace of Death by Carroll Cox Estes | 1955, ? year No. 184 | 1955, ? year No. 185 Too Lovely To Live by Ruth Fenisong | 1955, ? year No. 186 They All Bleed Red by Richard Sted | 
| 1956 
 
 | 1956, ? year No. 187 Buried for Pleasure (Abridged) by Edwin Crispin | 1956, ? date No. 188 The Blonde Betrayer by John Godey | 1956, ? date No. 189 Trap for a Redhead by Stuart Palmer | 1956, ? year No. 190 Trial And Terror by Lawrence Treat | 1956, ? year No. 191 Shroud for a Lady by Elizabeth Daly | 1956, ? year No. 192 Another Morgue Heard From by Frederick Davis | 1956, ? year No. 193 Catch and Kill by Nicholas Blake | 1956, ? year No. 194 Network of Fear by Alvin Yudkoff | 1956, ? year No. 195 No Time for Terror by Philip MacDonald | 1956, ? year No. 196 
  Murder Muscles In (abridged) by Max Franklin
 | 1955,  No. 197 Murder Makes an Entrance by Clarence Bidington Keeland | 1956, ? date No. 198 Black Alibi (abridged) by Cornell Woolrich | 
| 1957 
 
 | 1957, ? year No. 199 The Book of the Crime by Elizabeth Daly | 1957, ? year No. 200 A Dirty Way To Die by George Bagby | 1957, ? year No. 201 Tell Her It's Murder, Helen Reilly | 1957, ? year No. 202 Take One For Murder by M.E. Chaber | 1957, ? year No. 203 The Long Body by Helen Mccloy | 1957, ? year No. 204 
  I Wake Up Screaming by Steve Fisher
 | 1957, ? year No. 205 Don't Look Back (abridged) by Miram Borgenicht | 1957, ? year No. 206 
  The Black Angel by Cornell Woolrich
 | 1957, ? year No. 207 Hang The Man High by Geoggrey Household | 
| 1958 
 
 | Jan 1958, 
  THE ALMOST DEAD by William Herber
 | Mar 1958, ? date No. 208 The Deadly Truth (abridged) by Helen McCloy | May 1958, ? date No. 209 Bridge to Vengence (abridged from The Little Walls) by Winston Graham | 
| Name changed to  Bestseller Mystery Magazine | 
| 1958 
 
 | Jul 1958, v1#1 No. 210 
  Black Path of Fear by Cornell Woolrich
 | Sep 1958, v1#2 No. 211 
  Project: Murder by James M. Fox
 | Nov 1958, v1#3 No. 212 
  Wish you were Dead
 | 
| 1959 
 
 | Jan 1959, v1#4 No. 213 
  The Almost Dead by William Herber
 | Mar 1959, v1#5 No. 214 
  Wings of Death by Brandon Bird
 | May 1959, v1#6 No. 215 
  The Man on the Cliff by Andrew Garve
 | Jul 1959, v1#7 No. 216 
  The Dying Fall by Henry Wade
 | Sep 1959, v1#8 No. 217 
  First Class Murder by Doris Miles Disney
 | Nov 1959, v1#9 No. 218 | 
| 1960 
 
 | Jan 1960, v2#1 No. 219 
  The Man Who Didn't Fly by Margot Bennett
 | Mar 1960, v2#2 No. 220 | May 1960, v2#3 No. 221 Man in Ambush by Maurice Procter | Jul 1960, v2#4 No. 222 
  Sting of Death by Shelly Smith
 | Sep 1960, v2#5 No. 223 | Nov 1960, v2#6 No. 224 | 
| 1961 
 
 | Feb 1961, v3#1 No. 225 | Apr 1961, v3#2 No. 226 
  Murder In Eden Arthur W. Upfield
 |